RE: Naughty Dog vs Insomniac

Logged in as: Guest

RE: Naughty Dog vs Insomniac

Printable Version

All Forums >> [Gamers Lounge] >> Gaming Culture & Industry Discussion >> RE: Naughty Dog vs Insomniac

Page: << < prev 1 [2] 3 next > >>

Message

<< Older Topic Newer Topic >>

RE: Naughty Dog vs Insomniac - Aug.-1th-2008 2:00:03

ChefDejon

Posts: 611
Joined: Mar.-23th-2007
Status: online

quote:

ORIGINAL: Le-mo

quote:

ORIGINAL: sonarus

Uncharted is great but it could be better. More physics would be nice and online coop and multiplayer would be a great addition for the sequel

I don't care what anyone says i want multiplayer

Ya, that's my only complaint with Uncharted. I mean the game was built to have multiplayer but it didn't so it was disappointing. I got attacked when I said Uncharted would've been better if it had multiplayer functionality in Gamespot.

if it had multiplayer i prob wouldnt of ended up trading it in

(in reply to Le-mo)

Post #: 21

RE: Naughty Dog vs Insomniac - Aug.-1th-2008 2:00:10

sonarus

Posts: 5517
Joined: May-13th-2007
Status: offline

Insomniac gets awesomness points for being able to develop a ps3 game every yr. If naughty dog could step up to that level they would be ill. But they jsut don't have the man power. Insomniac is easily double their team

(in reply to Solid_Snake)

Post #: 22

RE: Naughty Dog vs Insomniac - Aug.-1th-2008 2:02:00

Solid_Snake

Posts: 1066
Joined: Feb.-25th-2008
Status: offline

quote:

ORIGINAL: Le-mo

quote:

ORIGINAL: sonarus

Uncharted is great but it could be better. More physics would be nice and online coop and multiplayer would be a great addition for the sequel

I don't care what anyone says i want multiplayer

Ya, that's my only complaint with Uncharted. I mean the game was built to have multiplayer but it didn't so it was disappointing. I got attacked when I said Uncharted would've been better if it had multiplayer functionality in Gamespot.

i would never mind multiplayer, but how would it be handled? I could see co-op; maybe play as sal. But he's not in it for most of the game; I think single player was fine for the first one, considering how the story worked out. But I wouldn't mind any multiplayer in the second. My biggest complaint was the size; I would like the game to be a bit more open. I understand it's not meant to be an open world, but they should open up several paths to get to the same place; it would make it much more interesting, and with several different puzzle elements, depending where you go.

_____________________________

Thats right... I AM dangerous

(in reply to Le-mo)

Post #: 23

RE: Naughty Dog vs Insomniac - Aug.-1th-2008 2:02:17

Whoooop

Posts: 1537
Joined: Mar.-22th-2007
Status: offline

Little bit of topic.. quick.

What do you guys think could work with Uncharted, online wise?? Death Match?? Puzzle Match??

_____________________________

(in reply to Le-mo)

Post #: 24

RE: Naughty Dog vs Insomniac - Aug.-1th-2008 2:02:30

Le-mo

Posts: 4882
Joined: Apr.-15th-2007
From: Seattle, Washington
Status: online

quote:

ORIGINAL: sonarus

Insomniac gets awesomness points for being able to develop a ps3 game every yr. If naughty dog could step up to that level they would be ill. But they jsut don't have the man power. Insomniac is easily double their team

Ya, imagine if Naughty Dog had more manpower. *Drools*

_____________________________

(in reply to sonarus)

Post #: 25

RE: Naughty Dog vs Insomniac - Aug.-1th-2008 2:07:23

Le-mo

Posts: 4882
Joined: Apr.-15th-2007
From: Seattle, Washington
Status: online

quote:

ORIGINAL: Solid_Snake

quote:

ORIGINAL: Le-mo

quote:

ORIGINAL: sonarus

Uncharted is great but it could be better. More physics would be nice and online coop and multiplayer would be a great addition for the sequel

I don't care what anyone says i want multiplayer

Ya, that's my only complaint with Uncharted. I mean the game was built to have multiplayer but it didn't so it was disappointing. I got attacked when I said Uncharted would've been better if it had multiplayer functionality in Gamespot.

i would never mind multiplayer, but how would it be handled? I could see co-op; maybe play as sal. But he's not in it for most of the game; I think single player was fine for the first one, considering how the story worked out. But I wouldn't mind any multiplayer in the second. My biggest complaint was the size; I would like the game to be a bit more open. I understand it's not meant to be an open world, but they should open up several paths to get to the same place; it would make it much more interesting, and with several different puzzle elements, depending where you go.

Ya, Uncharted should've been more open-world. I mean most of the times when I'm playing the game I just want to stop and explore the world, but there wasn't much to explore.

_____________________________

(in reply to Solid_Snake)

Post #: 26

RE: Naughty Dog vs Insomniac - Aug.-1th-2008 3:54:28

socomnick

Posts: 2097
Joined: Apr.-5th-2007
From: Happy Tree Land
Status: online

I definetely say naughty dog wins. Hands down they win

Now can we please compare some real devs ?

_____________________________

(in reply to Le-mo)

Post #: 27

RE: Naughty Dog vs Insomniac - Aug.-1th-2008 4:25:46

Shankle

Posts: 3706
Joined: Sep.-18th-2007
From: Britain
Status: online

quote:

ORIGINAL: socomnick
Now can we please compare some real devs ?

Like Bungie?

It's so difficult to choose between Insomniac and Naughty Dog. I always preferred Crash to Spyro, but then I preferred Ratchet and Clank to Jak and Daxter. Uncharted was better than Ratchet:TOD, but Insomniac do get props for pumping out brilliant games faster than anyone else in the industry (excluding sports devs) by a very large margin.
In the end I have to go with Naughty Dog due to nostalgia, and also to the fact that they made Crash Team Racing not just good, but even better than Mariokart.

_____________________________

"Oh, **** off, I'm Clive Owen; that's mental!"

(in reply to socomnick)

Post #: 28

RE: Naughty Dog vs Insomniac - Aug.-1th-2008 10:56:38

TwissT

Posts: 3645
Joined: Nov.-25th-2007
From: Toronto, Canada
Status: online

I say insomniac but by a very very small margin.

_____________________________

The Answer is 42

(in reply to Shankle)

Post #: 29

RE: Naughty Dog vs Insomniac - Aug.-1th-2008 10:58:04

Dont Panic

Posts: 791
Joined: Sep.-26th-2007
From: Colorado
Status: online

quote:

ORIGINAL: DarkSniper

Insomniac by a slight margin.

Same, pretty close though.

_____________________________

(in reply to DarkSniper)

Post #: 30

RE: Naughty Dog vs Insomniac - Aug.-1th-2008 11:38:27

mjones1994

Posts: 952
Joined: Jul.-13th-2008
From: England
Status: offline

In ps1 it was naughty dog. In ps2 Insomniac for R&C , Ps3 Insomniac just because i love resistance

OVERALL: INSOMNIAC

(in reply to Le-mo)

Post #: 31

RE: Naughty Dog vs Insomniac - Aug.-1th-2008 11:54:36

Violater

Posts: 496
Joined: Mar.-23th-2007
Status: online

They tie last 2 gens, Insomniac wins this Gen.

_____________________________

(in reply to Le-mo)

Post #: 32

RE: Naughty Dog vs Insomniac - Aug.-1th-2008 14:58:47

harry190

Posts: 4226
Joined: Feb.-10th-2008
From: Why do you want to know you BIG pervert
Status: offline

Jak and Daxter is my favourite Adventure/Platformer game and Crash Team Racing my favourite cart racing game.

Ratchet and Clank 2 was a masterpiece.

Currently,Insomniac is the best studio in the industry though.

_____________________________

I am your father and your mother.

(in reply to Violater)

Post #: 33

RE: Naughty Dog vs Insomniac - Aug.-3th-2008 22:27:03

xionpunk

Posts: 7
Joined: Jul.-4th-2007
Status: offline

I have loved every single game that Naughty Dog has created for sony. J&D one of my favorite series ever and Uncharted was unbelievably fun. The only Insomniac games I have played were the original Spyro and Ripto's Rage.I loved em both (though I was like 10.)

hmm.. I need a new J&D, an Uncharted sequel, and to get to work on some Insomniac games.

(in reply to harry190)

Post #: 34

RE: Naughty Dog vs Insomniac - Aug.-3th-2008 22:39:04

Shankle

Posts: 3706
Joined: Sep.-18th-2007
From: Britain
Status: online

quote:

ORIGINAL: Whoooop

Little bit of topic.. quick.

What do you guys think could work with Uncharted, online wise?? Death Match?? Puzzle Match??

Co-op for a start, but I'd love a deathmatch. Beating people up would be so much better if it was real people you were beating up.

_____________________________

"Oh, **** off, I'm Clive Owen; that's mental!"

(in reply to Whoooop)

Post #: 35

RE: Naughty Dog vs Insomniac - Aug.-3th-2008 23:25:26

smokeymicpot

Posts: 3333
Joined: Jan.-2th-2008
From: Who Watches the Watchmen.
Status: offline

You really can not choose between the both of them they both help each other make the games really. But if i had to choose i would pick Naughty Dog i love my old crash games

_____________________________

Psn smokeymicpot

(in reply to Shankle)

Post #: 36

RE: Naughty Dog vs Insomniac - Aug.-3th-2008 23:26:18

harry190

Posts: 4226
Joined: Feb.-10th-2008
From: Why do you want to know you BIG pervert
Status: offline

I just played Uncharted...amazing stuff.

_____________________________

I am your father and your mother.

(in reply to smokeymicpot)

Post #: 37

RE: Naughty Dog vs Insomniac - Aug.-4th-2008 7:33:04

Odion

Posts: 9582
Joined: Apr.-16th-2007
Status: offline

thats easy

BUNGIE!

_____________________________

Rujoshin on my ban- "Do the time, come back and leave the offensive commenting in the past is my advice. "

Thats a negative captain!